Carter Snead: A Stress Test for Notre Dame’s Catholic Mission

Sycamore Trust’s 2026 Annual Breakfast brought together alumni, parents, faculty, students, and friends of the University for a faithful and thoughtful discussion on the challenges and opportunities facing Notre Dame’s Catholic mission. This Bulletin is the first in a three-part series that will feature highlights from our three distinguished speakers.

We begin with Professor O. Carter Snead—Charles E. Rice Professor of Law and former director of Notre Dame’s de Nicola Center for Ethics and Culture.

In addition to our Annual Breakfast series, Sycamore readers should expect more Bulletins than usual during June as we continue our practice of reporting on developments related to the advancement of “Pride Month” and the LGBTQ+ agenda at Notre Dame.

We invite you to watch for these upcoming Bulletins and to share them with others who care about preserving Notre Dame as a beacon of Catholic faith and intellectual excellence.

Support Our Common Purpose

Please consider a gift to our year-end campaign. Your support provides the resources we need to continue the fight for Notre Dame’s Catholic identity—to keep the one true light shining on the Dome.

Support Sycamore

Introduction

Introducing Professor Snead, Sycamore Trust Board President Dr. Steve O’Neil, ND ’87, highlighted his national reputation as a leading Catholic scholar and public intellectual whose work has explored the moral foundations of law, medicine, and public life. “In an age that often prizes radical individual autonomy above all else,” O’Neil observed,

Professor Snead reminds us of a more fully human vision—one rooted in dependence, vulnerability, family, community, and mutual obligation.

Professor Snead began by thanking Sycamore Trust for its longstanding efforts on behalf of Notre Dame’s Catholic mission, describing the organization as: 

One of the key bulwarks against the dimming of that light and the fading of that beacon that Notre Dame represents to the world.

Measuring Catholic identity

To evaluate Notre Dame’s Catholic identity, Snead turned to the University’s Mission Statement. He highlighted its declaration that Notre Dame’s Catholic character “depends upon…the continuing presence of a predominant number of Catholic intellectuals,” describing this commitment as “a mandate for mission hiring.”

According to Snead, the health of Notre Dame’s Catholic mission ultimately rests upon four essential elements: students, faculty, leadership, and the Congregation of Holy Cross.

Of these, he emphasized, faculty hiring remains especially important, saying, “faculty is the ballgame.”

Faculty hiring and faculty retention is the linchpin of preserving the mission of the University of Notre Dame—its Catholic mission and its mission to be an excellent elite institution.

For that reason, the University cannot sustain its mission unless it intentionally hires and retains scholars who understand, support, and contribute to that mission.

Despite ongoing challenges, Snead sees reason for optimism. He pointed to the flourishing Sorin Fellows program, Notre Dame Right to Life, The Irish Rover, the Knights of Columbus, The Liturgical Choir, and a number of faithful Catholic scholars on the faculty. Snead also pointed to the de Nicola Center’s Mission Hiring Initiative, which has already funded eleven faculty positions across multiple departments and helped recruit scholars committed to advancing Notre Dame’s distinctive Catholic intellectual mission.

He rejected the notion that Catholic identity and academic excellence are somehow in tension. In his view, Notre Dame is strongest when it embraces what makes it distinctive.

Reflecting on the temptation to imitate elite secular institutions, Snead warned:

We’ve been tempted by elite culture to suppress what’s distinctive about ourselves as Catholics so that we’ll be accepted.

But that path, he argued, ultimately fails.

The people you’re trying to imitate don’t respect you. They don’t admire your desire to be at the table with them.

Instead:

Notre Dame is at its best when it’s at its most distinctive.

The Ostermann Controversy

Snead then turned to the controversy surrounding the appointment of Associate Professor Susan Osterman as director of the Liu Institute.

The appointment generated widespread concern because of Osterman’s repeated public criticism of the Catholic Church’s pro-life teaching and Notre Dame’s institutional commitment to defending unborn life.

In discussing why the appointment was untenable, Snead focused on the difference between faculty positions and institutional leadership, emphasizing

You can’t appoint people to leadership of administrative roles who don’t support the mission of the institution itself.

Sycamore readers will recall that we have discussed Professor Osterman’s objectionable views. What deepened the problem, as Snead pointed out, was the decision to place someone who had repeatedly and publicly opposed a core element of Notre Dame’s mission into a senior administrative leadership role.

Following objections from bishops, students, alumni, and faculty members, Professor Osterman ultimately stepped down before assuming the directorship.

A "Stress Test" of Notre Dame's Catholic Identity

Snead described the controversy as a “stress test” of Notre Dame’s Catholic identity, noting that students performed exceptionally well.

Our students acquitted themselves in my judgment in a very beautiful way.

He praised Notre Dame Right to Life, The Irish Rover, and student leaders for responding with courage, clarity, and charity — and, once the controversy was resolved, for choosing prayer and gratitude rather than triumphalism.

We have reported on the several faculty members, Father Miscamble chief among them, who spoke out publicly against the Ostermann appointment here, here, and here – and Snead praised others who worked quietly behind the scenes to encourage a constructive resolution. 

(For more on the faculty problem see our forthcoming Bulletin in this series on Bill Dempsey’s Breakfast remarks.)

Vigilance and Hope

The Ostermann appointment not only conflicted with the University’s mission but also exposed deeper institutional problems, including what Snead identified as

shortcomings in the University’s process for evaluating mission alignment in senior administrative appointments.

Yet, as Snead noted, it also demonstrated that Notre Dame has a defense against secularization in its students, faculty, alumni, bishops, and members of Holy Cross who responded faithfully and effectively to protect the University’s mission.

That should encourage everyone who loves Notre Dame, he offered—but not to the point of complacency. As Snead reminded those gathered:

If Notre Dame loses its Catholic mission, the world and the Church has lost something beautiful and important and countercultural.

Snead concluded his remarks with a challenge to all who care about the University:

We all have an obligation every day to get up and redouble our efforts and work tirelessly and relentlessly to make this place worthy of the name of the Blessed Mother.

Support Our Common Purpose

If you share our love for Notre Dame and want to see an authentic Catholic renewal under the Dome, please consider lending a hand in whatever way you are able — by giving of your time (especially in prayer), talent, or treasure. The funds we receive are used to continue our work to keep you informed of Notre Dame’s imperiled Catholic identity, organize events and activities to strengthen our collective voice, and financially support the efforts on campus by students and their organizations to stand tall for the Truth of Catholicism.

Oremus

O God of Truth and Love, You have called us into a loving and faithful relationship with You. Your Son identified Himself as the Way, the Truth, and the Life, and called us to follow Him wherever He goes.

In their care for and guardianship of the University and the students it serves, may the administrators of the University of Notre Dame always commit themselves to the pursuit and embrace of the Truth, which alone can set us free.

May the Holy Spirit lead them into all truth and recall them to it in times of peril. May they embrace the sorrow that comes from being different from, and rejected by, the world, so that they may rejoice always in the goodness of the Lord.

In the day of battle, may they joyfully take courage in Him who has already overcome the world.

We make our prayer through the intercession of Notre Dame, Our Mother, and in the Name of Jesus, Your Son, who lives and reigns with You, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, God, forever and ever. Amen.

The above prayer is by Sycamore Trustee Father John Raphael (’89). To join us in regular prayer projects such as our Novena for Catholic Education and our Meditation on the 12-Days of Christmas, please join our Apostolate.

Submit Your Mass Intention

Father John J. Raphael (’89) offers a monthly Mass for the intentions of our Sycamore Trust community. If you have an intention that you would like him to include at his next Mass, you may submit it by clicking on the following button.

2 Responses

  1. J.M.J.

    Some will claim that Genesis is not a Scientific explanation for how God Created The Universe, but simply an explanation for why God Created The Universe, but that is not entirely True, for when God Said, “Let there be Light” God Willed The Laws of Physics into existence.

    In The Beginning, God Said “Let there be Light” and God Willed The Creation of The Laws Of Physics – Google Search

    “The Universe as a whole does not experience night and day”, but the Earth does, because God placed The Earth in the perfect location between the Sun and the Moon to sustain Human Life.

    For Catholics, having already been converted, we believe that The Will Of God, The Most Holy And Undivided Blessed Trinity, Who Willed The Creation Of The Universe Out Of Perfect Divine Eternal Infinite Love, Is not “a theory of everything “, God ‘s Will Is The Source Of Divine Creation, and thus The Purpose of Everything.

    A Catholic University, has both a Religious and a moral obligation, as a Catholic University, to remain in Communion with Christ And His One, Holy, Catholic, And Apostolic Church, In The Unity Of The Holy Ghost, for a Catholic University, in order to be, in essence, Catholic, cannot follow the same standards of academic inquiry and “freedom” as secular universities, thus denying God’s Will Is The Source Of Divine Creation, without ipso facto denying Sacred Tradition, Sacred Scripture, and The Teaching Of The True Magisterium Of Christ’s Church, The Deposit Of Faith Christ Has Entrusted To His One, Holy, Catholic, And Apostolic Church, For The Salvation Of Souls, and in essence, defecting from The Catholic Church.

    “You cannot be My disciples if you do not Abide In My Word.” – The Charitable Anathema Of Jesus The Christ, The Word Of Perfect Divine Eternal Infinite Love Incarnate

    God’s Universal Call To Holiness, is a Call to be chaste in our thoughts, in our words, and in our deeds, “aligning all our desires, our words, and our actions with moral purity, and thus be “Temples of The Holy Ghost” in all our relationships.

    The Holy Ghost (The Spirit Of Perfect Divine Eternal Infinite Love Between The Father And His Only Begotten Son, Jesus The Christ, Who Proceeds From Both The Father And His Only Begotten Son, Jesus The Christ) , “Dwells in The Catholic Church In each member, providing The Gifts and Fruits that makes The Churches Members Holy.”

    Only Christ’s One, Holy, Catholic, And Apostolic Church, In The Unity of The Holy Ghost, Serves for The Salvation of Souls, and thus for Human Flourishing.

    “When the freedom to be creative becomes the freedom to create oneself, then necessarily the Maker Himself is denied and ultimately man too is stripped of his dignity as a creature of God, as the image of God at the core of his being. The defence of the family is about man himself. And it becomes clear that when God is denied, human dignity also disappears. Whoever defends God is defending man.” – Pope Benedict’s Christmas Address 2012 –

    Pope Benedict’s warning about the consequences of rejecting the fact that God Is The Source Of Divine Creation, The Author of Love, of Life, And of Marriage, and thus The Author of our Unalienable Right to Life, to Liberty, and to The Pursuit of Happiness, while illuminating the error of the modernists who claim, “If there is a union of a private nature there is neither a third party ( No Holy Ghost), nor is Society affected”, ipso facto, denying Our Universal Call To Holiness Is A Call To Be Temples Of The Holy Ghost, in all our relationships and that sin done in private is still sin, which is an offense against The Most Holy Blessed Trinity, and thus an offense against The Sanctity and Dignity of Human Life from the moment of conception. In fact, by retaining The “forever” Office of The MUNUS, and resigning the Ministerial Office, one could rightly conclude that he contributed to The Lifting of Our Lady’s Veil, exposing the counterfeit magisterium that has been attempting, for sometime now, to subsist within The One Body Of Christ while denying God’s Universal Call To Be Temples Of The Holy Ghost In All Our Relationships.

    “Behold your Mother.”- Christ On The Cross

    “For where your treasure is there will your heart be also.”

    Let Us Rejoice “At the heart of Liberty Is Christ, “4For it is impossible for those who were once illuminated, have tasted also the heavenly gift and were made partakers of the Holy Ghost, 5Have moreover tasted the good word of God and the powers of the world to come…”, to not believe that Christ’s Sacrifice On The Cross will lead us to Salvation, but we must desire forgiveness for our sins, and accept Salvational Love, God’s Gift Of Grace And Mercy; believe in The Power And The Glory Of Salvation Love, and rejoice in the fact that No Greater Love Is There Than This, To Desire Salvation For One’s Beloved.

    “Hail The Cross, Our Only Hope.”

    “Blessed are those Called to The Wedding Supper Of The Lamb.”

    May Our Blessed Mother’s Immaculate Heart Triumph soon, restoring Peace in Her Son’s One Holy, Catholic, And Apostolic Church. ✝️

    Love The, Notre Dame!

  2. When we were in the initial stages of founding Southern Catholic College, the University of Dallas had a new president, and the administration decided to “loosen up” some Theology and Philosophy requirements. This led to a change in the core curriculum, which in turn caused several elite faculty members to leave the institution. Instead of an increase in student population, a decrease followed. Why? They had abandoned the university’s differentiator. This change was rolled back several years later, but the damage was done. The key faculty losses never came back. It took more than a decade to restore its place. I hope Notre Dame leadership is cognizant.

print

Contact